Gen Z, Boomers, and the marketing myth that won’t die

At some point in almost every marketing meeting, someone says it. “But how do we reach Gen Z?” And everyone nods gravely, as though Gen Z were a newly discovered tribe in the Amazon rather than a made-up bracket of birth years that happens to include both a 13-year-old on TikTok and a 28-year-old with a mortgage and a bad back.
We have all agreed to take this deeply seriously. There are conferences. There are consultants. There are slide decks with little cartoon avatars: the Boomer with reading glasses, the Millennial clutching an avocado, the Gen Z-er who apparently communicates exclusively in emoji and disappointment. And underneath all of it sits a slightly awkward fact that the entire industry would prefer you didn’t google.
The generations, in the way marketers use them, mostly aren’t real.

A man named Costanza ruined the party

Here’s where it gets uncomfortable for the avatar people. A researcher called David Costanza, then at George Washington University, did the thing nobody selling “generational strategy” ever seems to do: he actually checked.
He and his colleagues ran a meta-analysis, which is the scientific equivalent of not trusting one study but stacking up loads of them and looking at the whole pile. Nearly twenty thousand people, across the classic generational brackets, measured on the stuff everyone claims differs wildly by generation. The finding, published back in 2012 and echoed by later work: the meaningful differences between generations basically weren’t there. What tiny differences did show up were better explained by other things entirely, like age, or life stage, or simply what’s going on in the economy that year.
Put more bluntly than a journal would, and one review of his work did put it this way: the popular “generations at work” claims are, and I’m quoting the polite academic summary loosely here, probably nonsense. There is little solid evidence the differences exist, and almost no theory for why they even should.
And here’s a detail that should make you laugh and wince at once. When researchers went looking, they found the studies couldn’t even agree on when a generation starts and ends. The birth-year ranges wander around depending on who’s doing the defining. We built an entire marketing discipline on categories whose boundaries nobody actually agrees on. It’s astrology for people with a media budget.

Why the myth is so cosy (and so expensive)

So why won’t it die? Because it’s wonderfully convenient. “Gen Z wants authenticity” is an easier sentence to put in a deck than “different humans want different things for reasons that don’t fit neatly on a timeline.” Generations give you tidy boxes, and tidy boxes feel like strategy. They let you feel you understand millions of people without having to look at any of them.
They’re also flattering to the person holding the marker. Sorting the entire population into four or five confident little stereotypes feels like insight. It’s the same comfort as a horoscope: vague enough to always sort of fit, specific enough to feel clever.
The trouble is that the boxes quietly send your money the wrong way. If you’re convinced “Boomers don’t buy online” (they do, in enormous numbers) or “Gen Z has no attention span” (they’ll happily watch forty minutes of something they care about), you’ll build campaigns for cartoon people instead of real ones. And cartoon people, famously, don’t have wallets.

What’s actually going on instead

None of this means everyone is identical, obviously. People clearly differ. The point is that the year you were born is a rotten way to predict how you shop. It’s a proxy, and a lazy one, standing in for the things that actually drive behaviour.
Take the classic “Gen Z lives on their phone.” Sort of true, but not because of some mystical generational essence. It’s because they came of age when phones were the default, and, crucially, plenty of 60-year-olds are now glued to theirs too. The behaviour tracks the situation, not the birth certificate. What you’re usually seeing when you think you’ve spotted a “generational trait” is really just life stage (a 22-year-old and a 55-year-old are at different points, of course they buy differently), or plain access to technology, or how much money is in the account this month. Those are real, useful, targetable things. “Generation” is the costume they’re wearing.
Which is oddly good news, because those real drivers are things you can actually find out about your specific customers, instead of guessing from a stereotype a consultant sold you.

So the next time someone says “how do we reach Gen Z”

Try gently swapping the question. Not “what does this generation want,” but “what does the specific person we’re trying to reach actually need, where are they, and what’s going on in their life when they’d buy this.” Less catchy. Considerably more accurate. Doesn’t come with a fun avatar, sadly.

Because your customer was never really a generation. They were always just a person, with a particular problem, a budget, and a limited amount of patience, none of which is printed on their birth year. And people, it turns out, are worth getting to know one at a time.