Ask a business owner who their customer is, and a certain kind of person will puff up slightly and say: “Well, really, everyone.” As if that’s the confident answer. As if casting the widest possible net is obviously the clever move, and only a coward would narrow it.
That word, “everyone,” has quietly cost more businesses more money than any recession. It just does it slowly, and politely, so nobody notices the bleeding.
Here’s the thing nobody wants to hear on a Monday: when you talk to everyone, you talk to no one. Not because it’s a nice slogan for a marketing poster, but because of how human attention actually works. We are all walking around scanning for “this is for me.” A message built to offend nobody and fit everybody sails straight past that filter, because it never once says “you.” It’s beige. And nobody has ever fallen in love with beige.
Why “everyone” feels safe and isn’t
Let’s be fair to the instinct, because it comes from somewhere reasonable. Narrowing down feels like turning away business. If I say I’m for small e-commerce brands, doesn’t that mean the big manufacturer scrolls past? What if I need that manufacturer? Better to keep the door open to all of them, surely.
It feels like maths. More people addressed equals more people interested. Except that’s not how persuasion works at all. The manufacturer doesn’t think “she only mentioned webshops, so she can’t possibly help me.” The manufacturer thinks “she clearly knows exactly who she’s for and speaks about it with total confidence, so she probably knows her stuff.” Specificity doesn’t read as “not for me.” It reads as expertise. And expertise is attractive to everyone, including the people you didn’t technically name.
So the paradox, and it really is one: the more precisely you describe one type of customer, the more different kinds of customer trust you. Vague is what actually turns people away. It just does it so quietly you blame the algorithm instead.
Watch what happens when you get specific
Picture two accountants, same street, same prices.
The first says: “We provide accounting services for businesses and individuals.” True, complete, and instantly forgotten. Your eyes have already moved on. It’s the visual equivalent of hold music.
The second says: “We do the books for freelancers and small webshops who’d rather eat glass than open a spreadsheet.” You smiled. You also, if that’s you, felt a tiny jolt of “oh, them.” That accountant just became a real, specific, human thing in your mind, and the first one is still hold music. Same service. Same competence, probably. Completely different fate, decided entirely by whether they had the nerve to be for someone in particular.
Notice the second one didn’t even list more services. It listed fewer, and described them with personality, and that made it feel like more. Being specific isn’t shrinking your offer. It’s giving people a door they can actually see, instead of a blank wall with “all welcome” written on it in small grey type.
But I really do serve lots of different people
Fine. Many businesses genuinely do. The plumber fixes taps for pensioners and property developers alike. This is where people throw up their hands and retreat to “everyone” as if it’s the only honest option.
It isn’t. You don’t have to pick one customer and abandon the rest. You have to pick who you talk to first, in this message, on this page, in this ad. You can speak directly to the frazzled webshop owner today and the manufacturer next week. What you can’t do is speak to both in the same breath and expect either to feel it. A message is not a buffet. It’s a conversation, and conversations have someone on the other end. One someone.
The businesses that feel like they’re “for everyone” almost never got there by trying to be. They got there by being unmistakably for someone, becoming known and trusted, and expanding outward from that solid little core. Nobody builds a reputation on beige. They build it on being sharply, memorably, slightly riskily for a particular person, and then letting that reputation spill over.
So, before you write “everyone” again
Try the uncomfortable version. Finish this sentence out loud: “We’re really for the kind of person who…” and don’t let yourself off the hook with “anyone.” Push until it’s a specific human with a specific problem you can picture at a specific kitchen table.
It’ll feel like you’re narrowing. You’re not. You’re finally pointing at someone instead of gesturing vaguely at a crowd. And the funny thing, the thing that catches people out every time, is that the moment you stop trying to be for everyone is usually the moment everyone starts paying attention.
Beige is safe. Beige is also invisible. Pick a person. Say their name, even if only in your own head. The rest tends to follow.





